.
Eulogy to the First Ms. Brown
or a Divine Comedy of Educators
.
To my aunt—the second daughter of three,
And first to leave us just two years ago:
I picture you once sitting on Grandpa’s knee
And asking him, where do our spirits go
When they leave earth? I’m sure he gave a wry
Teacher’s reply to you, and that a show
Of hands shot up with questions, whys on whys,
If his students happened to hear it. That’s
How it goes for us teachers—ever-wise
We aim and aim to be, as citizens cast
Us onto thrones of gold and wild guesses,
What a view! Did it ever feel too vast
To you, Aunt Lin, that map that curses, blesses
Us with endless, shining roads?
I don’t know, I say again. It messes
With me, cruel doubt, and gnaws and pokes and goads—
Doubt about adding, atoms, afterlife,
Doubt about what might survive or explode—
You were a science teacher, not a wife
Or parent, but a mother all the same,
Wielding goggles and a dissecting-knife
And making children doubt and doubt again
Till lights shot up among the field of hands
And all stood, silent, staring at the flame,
The conflagration on their tiny land
Of learning, the fruit of their labors long,
A flash of something true, of something grand,
Hard to explain in lab report or song:
A consolation. Is that where you are?
I see you shining somewhere in a throng
Of light, and heat, and burning—much like a star,
But vaster. Still, the children want to know—
Is that where you are? Is that where we’ll go?
.
.
Manhattan
In Midtown, massive cavern of my youth,
Skyscrapers flashed with phantoms of the truth,
All screens and sun-shadows along the walls
On either side like brick and metal jaws.
Within it rushed the world, in shoes and buses,
Fodder for New York’s never-sated trusses,
And deeper, in its groaning gut, the train
Twisted inside its middle like a chain.
We took that train each Monday. You were eight,
And danced effortlessly over curb and grate
And didn’t know what half the ads were saying.
The city couldn’t comprehend your playing.
And when the weather got crueler and colder
You sat there with me, ear upon my shoulder,
And round us roared the city, like a storm.
The earth cried out. Something was being born.
.
.
Betsy K. Brown is a teacher and chair of humanities at an Arizona high school, and a graduate of Seattle Pacific University’s MFA in Creative Writing program. She has been previously published in First Things, The Classical Outlook, and Autumn Sky Poetry. Her poetry collection, City Nave, will be published by Wipf and Stock this summer. You can read more of my work at betsykbrown.com.
1. Eulogy: That is a beautiful eulogy for your sister (I presume) and for someone who was obviously a great educator. As you intimated in your eulogy, the reward is seeing the faces of students light up with learning.
2. Manhattan: I can envision the endless hours spent commuting. I was particularly taken with your description of “…the train/Twisted inside its middle like a chain.” Euphonic and alliterative.
Thank you, Roy! My aunt (the teacher in the first poem) was indeed an excellent woman and educator. I am glad you like the chain imagery. I teach Plato’s Republic to 11th graders, so I had fun making connections.
Two very beautiful poems. The first is sentimental, has a light tone, and is very detailed. Manhattan is an excellent cityscape piece with its very descriptive lines and sets of images, such as screens and sun-shadows appearing like brick and metal jaws and the train like a chain inside its gut. In fact, likening the city to a cavern is a wonderful conceit in itself. Thank you for these pieces, Betsy.
Thank you for your thoughts on these, Shamik. I hope you think of the cavern imagery again the next time you walk down the street in a very tall city.
Nice work, Betsy. I’m sure we will be seeing more of you.